Refactoring

Share this post

Performance Reviews πŸ…

refactoring.fm

Performance Reviews πŸ…

A first-principles approach to performance management + a practical workflow + wild ideas from successful companies.

Luca Rossi
May 18, 2023
βˆ™ Paid
12
Share
Share this post

Performance Reviews πŸ…

refactoring.fm
Upgrade to paid to play voiceover

In any company, you would be hard pressed to find any process that impacts people’s behavior more than performance reviews.

People may ignore the company’s mission, principles, the supposed culture, but never ignore how their performance is evaluated. For this reason, reviews have the power to shape culture more than anything else β€” by rewarding good behavior and correcting bad one.

Yet, there isn’t much consensus on how to have them.

Sure, we have plenty of examples, usually from big tech, but most other companies use their own recipes, which are sometimes similar, sometimes remarkably different.

Some companies don’t have reviews at all, some run committees, some run peer-based processes, and more.

So, today, like we often do on Refactoring, we will unpack this by reasoning from first principles. We will figure out the goals of performance reviews, list various approaches, and evaluate upsides and downsides.

Here is what we will cover:

  • 🎯 Why we have reviews β€” let’s not take anything for granted.

  • 🍱 What goes into a review β€” work summary, feedback, and goals.

  • πŸ™‹β€β™‚οΈ Who contributes to the review β€” the role of subjects, managers, and peers.

  • 🀝 How to have the review β€” a practical, step-by-step process.

  • πŸ”€ Alternative approaches β€” case studies from unconventional companies like Valve, Netflix, Morning Star, and more.

  • πŸ“š Resources β€” templates, articles, and books to learn more.

Let’s dive in!

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
Β© 2023 Refactoring ETS
Privacy βˆ™ Terms βˆ™ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
SubstackΒ is the home for great writing